Reporters Without Borders has learned that a
British company, Silver Bullet, and a US company, Verint Systems (a subsidiary
of Comverse Technology), sold equipment for intercepting mobile phone calls
to the Vietnamese intelligence services. The source of this information, the
UK-based Jane’s
Defence Weekly, said a subsidiary of Israel Aircraft Industries acted as intermediary
in some of the sales.
“We are appalled to learn that our phone calls
with Vietnamese cyber-dissidents have been monitored with equipment provided
by European and US companies,” the
press freedom organisation said. “Coming a year after it emerged that
Yahoo! cooperates with the Chinese police, this new case reinforces our conviction
that telecommunications companies must be forced to respect certain rules of
ethical conduct. In particular, they should be banned from selling surveillance
equipment to repressive governments.”
The sales were revealed by Robert Karniol in an article
headlined “Vietnamese
army enhances mobile phone monitoring” in the 31 October 2005 issue of
Jane’s Defence Weekly (JDW). He said the London-based Silver Bullet
had recently sold two P-GSM stations (portable mobile phone listening devices
- see image) to Vietnam for $250,000 each. Elta (a subsidiary of Israel Aircraft
Industries) and Aikap Group, another Israeli company, acted as intermediaries
in this transaction.
The JDW article said the equipment sold by Silver Bullet complemented similar
equipment provided to Vietnam in 2002 by the US-based company Verint Systems.
Verint is a subsidiary of Comserve Technology, a telecommunications company
quoted on the Nasdaq exchange whose former boss, Kobi Alexander, is wanted
by the FBI for securities fraud and is a fugitive from justice.
Reporters Without Borders tried to contact Silver Bullet and Verint Systems
yesterday, but nobody in either company was available to comment on the JDW
article. The organisation found information about the P-GSM interception system
on the Silver Bullet site yesterday, but the site was down this morning.
The JDW article was picked up yesterday in the newsletter
published by an organisation that defends the rights of Vietnam’s Montagnard
people.